‘Abd-Allah ibn ‘Abbas said: The best reason for the metropolis is going amerikanska med Grekisk kvinnor to be found and homosexual might be thrown direct earliest from it, then stones should be thrown during the your.
When Allah mentioned zina, The guy demonstrated it as a “high sin” (fahishah – indefinite) among most other higher sins, nevertheless when He mentioned homosexuality, The guy entitled it “the new terrible sin” (al-fahishah – definite)
Ibn ‘Abbas is but one just who narrated in the Prophet (serenity and you can blessings away from Allah feel abreast of your) the text: “Anyone who you will find starting the experience of the people out of Lut, execute the one who can it additionally the one to whom it is complete.” This is narrated of the people of al-Sunan and you can is classed while the sahih by Ibn Hibban while others. Imam Ahmad quoted that it hadith since the evidence, and its isnad fits the conditions off al-Bukhari.
It told you: and it is narrated which he told you: “May Allah curse the one who does the experience of one’s folks of Lut, will get Allah curse the person who really does the experience of the people of Lut, may Allah curse the one who does the experience of individuals of Lut,” and is maybe not narrated that he cursed the brand new adulterer three moments in one hadith. This new Friends of your own Messenger regarding Allah (peace and you will blessings from Allah end up being on your) assented unanimously the homosexual is going to be performed, and not one of them differed regarding the one. Rather it differed to what type delivery. Some people believed that so it differences required that they disagreed throughout the carrying out your, so they narrated it an issue regarding the that your Friends differed, but it’s an issue about the and therefore there is opinion among them, not a question of improvement.
The guy cursed individuals who do various major sins, however, the guy didn’t curse them over and over again, but he frequent the fresh new curse into homosexual 3 times
“And been not near to illegal sex. Verily, it is good Fahishah (i.age. anything that transgresses their restrictions: a good sin), and you will a bad means (leading you to hell unless of course Allah Forgives your) .” [al-Isra ] and you will what He says on the homosexuality (translation of meaning):
“And (remember) Lut (Lot), as he considered his people: Are you willing to going the fresh terrible sin such as for instance nothing preceding you has committed about ‘Alamin (humankind and you will jinn)?.” [al-A’raf eight:80] will discover the essential difference between them. This suggests that it consists of all substance of evil and you can sin.” (Al-Jawab al-Kafi (p. 260-263)
“Pertaining to homosexuality, a few of the students asserted that the newest discipline for it is actually exactly like the new abuse to possess zina, plus it was mentioned that it is lower than one. Nevertheless correct view on that your Companions was in fact unanimously agreed is that they are both are murdered, brand new active as well as the inactive people, if they is actually married or otherwise not.
New article writers off al-Sunan narrated off Ibn ‘Abbas (could possibly get Allah appreciate your) that Prophet (peace and you will blessings away from Allah getting on him) said: “Anybody who you notice starting the action of those from Lut, do the one who will it and one exactly who it is complete.” And Abu Dawud narrated of Ibn ‘Abbas about the unmarried people which commits a good homosexual operate he told you: He is become stoned. And one similar try narrated out of ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib (will get Allah appreciate him). The brand new Companions don’t disagree regarding governing your homosexual is going to be executed, however they differed concerning the steps. It actually was narrated out-of Abu Bakr al-Siddiq (will get Allah be pleased with your) that he is to-be burned, and out of anybody else that he is getting executed.